Blog Layout

Mental Health and Disability Claims: What You Need to Know in Ontario

Person struggling with mental health challenges affecting daily life.

Mental health issues can significantly affect daily functioning, often leading to difficulties in maintaining employment. In Ontario, if a mental health condition prevents you from working, you may be eligible for long term disability (LTD) benefits. However, proving a mental health-related disability can be challenging. This article will cover the essentials of making a mental health disability claim in Ontario, the documentation required, and how to handle common issues like claim denials.

Understanding Long Term Disability for Mental Health Conditions

Long term disability benefits are designed to provide financial support if you are unable to work due to a health condition. For many, mental health conditions like depression, anxiety, PTSD, or bipolar disorder can be just as disabling as physical illnesses. In Ontario, mental health can indeed be grounds for an LTD claim, but demonstrating the severity of your condition can be more difficult than with physical injuries.

Challenges in Proving Mental Health-Related Disability

Mental health disabilities are often more difficult to prove because they rely on subjective symptoms rather than objective evidence. Unlike physical conditions, mental health issues often depend on reports of symptoms such as fatigue, feelings of hopelessness, or difficulty concentrating, which can be harder for insurers to quantify. There are no tests that definitively demonstrate the existence of a mental health diagnosis the way imaging can reveal a broken bone, so claims must rely on clinical evaluations and patient self-reports.


These factors make it essential to provide the right documentation to support your claim.

Essential Documentation for Mental Health Disability Claims

To improve the chances of having your mental health disability claim approved, you need comprehensive documentation:

  1. Medical Records: Regular treatment notes from your healthcare providers, showing consistent care and tracking of your condition over time, are essential.
  2. Specialist Reports: Detailed assessments from psychiatrists, psychologists, or other mental health professionals should outline your diagnosis, symptoms, and how these symptoms impact your daily life.
  3. Treatment Plans: Documentation of the treatments you’ve tried, such as medication or therapy, and their effectiveness or any difficulties experienced in following these treatments can help illustrate the ongoing nature of your disability.
  4. Employer's Statements: Statements from your employer or colleagues can be valuable in demonstrating how your condition has impacted your ability to perform work-related tasks.
  5. Personal Journals or Logs: Maintaining a record of your symptoms and how they affect your day-to-day life can support your case by providing a detailed history of your disability.
Stack of medical documents and doctor's notes required for mental health disability claims.

Common Reasons Why Insurers Deny Mental Health Disability Claims

Despite providing documentation, mental health disability claims may be denied for several reasons. One common reason is insufficient medical evidence; insurers may assert that the documentation does not adequately demonstrate the severity of the condition or its impact on your ability to work. Non-compliance with prescribed treatments is another issue; if you have not followed all recommended treatments, insurers may use this as a basis for denying your claim, asserting that you are not taking necessary steps to improve your condition.


Pre-existing condition clauses can also be a factor, where policies may contain exclusions for conditions that existed before the insurance policy took effect. Additionally, insurers often cite a lack of objective evidence, claiming that because mental health conditions do not show up on traditional diagnostic tests, there isn’t enough proof to support your disability.

What to Do If Your Claim Is Denied

If your long term disability claim for a mental health condition is denied, there are several steps you can take to appeal the decision:

  1. Understand the Reason for Denial: Carefully review the denial letter to understand the insurer's specific reasons for rejecting your claim.
  2. Seek Legal Advice: Consulting a disability lawyer in Ontario can provide guidance on your legal rights and the best approach for appealing a denial.

How Can Aaron Waxman and Associates, P.C. Help?

Disability lawyer consulting with a client about appealing a denied claim.

If your long term disability claim for a mental health condition has been denied, the lawyers at Aaron Waxman and Associates, P.C. can provide the legal support you need. Our team of disability lawyers in Ontario is well-versed in handling cases involving mental health-related claims. We understand the challenges of proving a disability claim and can help you gather the right evidence to strengthen your case.


We offer personalized advice and support throughout the appeals process, helping you navigate the complexities of the insurance system and fight for the benefits you deserve. Contact us today at 416-661-4878 ext. 222 or awaxman@awaxmanlaw.ca for a free consultation and let us help you understand your rights and options.

We offer a free initial consultation that can be arranged at a date and time of your choosing and at your convenience.

Recent posts from our Knowledge Centre

Frustrated employee sitting at a desk, concerned about wrongful dismissal.
By Dev Ops December 30, 2024
Learn about wrongful dismissal in Ontario, including your legal rights, common misconceptions, and what steps to take next. Contact Aaron Waxman and Associates, P.C. for legal support.
Close-up of two damaged cars at night with police lights in the background.
By Dev Ops December 27, 2024
Learn the essential steps to protect your rights after a car accident in Ontario, including dealing with insurance companies and why contacting a car accidents lawyer is crucial.
Person walking on an icy surface wearing winter boots with thick soles.
By Dev Ops December 20, 2024
Learn essential winter safety tips to avoid slip and fall injuries. Discover what to do if you’re hurt on public or private property, and how Aaron Waxman and Associates, P.C. can help.
Crowded retail space during the holiday season.
By Dev Ops December 17, 2024
Injured in a slip and fall accident while holiday shopping? Learn what steps to take, how to document your case, and when to contact lawyers for slip and fall accidents in Ontario.
Show More
Frustrated employee sitting at a desk, concerned about wrongful dismissal.
By Dev Ops December 30, 2024
Learn about wrongful dismissal in Ontario, including your legal rights, common misconceptions, and what steps to take next. Contact Aaron Waxman and Associates, P.C. for legal support.
Close-up of two damaged cars at night with police lights in the background.
By Dev Ops December 27, 2024
Learn the essential steps to protect your rights after a car accident in Ontario, including dealing with insurance companies and why contacting a car accidents lawyer is crucial.
Person walking on an icy surface wearing winter boots with thick soles.
By Dev Ops December 20, 2024
Learn essential winter safety tips to avoid slip and fall injuries. Discover what to do if you’re hurt on public or private property, and how Aaron Waxman and Associates, P.C. can help.
Crowded retail space during the holiday season.
By Dev Ops December 17, 2024
Injured in a slip and fall accident while holiday shopping? Learn what steps to take, how to document your case, and when to contact lawyers for slip and fall accidents in Ontario.
top 100 canada law blog award
  • This blog is for informational purposes only and is not meant to substitute legal advice. Please read our disclaimer for further information.
  • All of our lawyers are licensed by The Law Society of Upper Canada
  • Office in Toronto and able to represent people in the province of Ontario
Share by: